Delightful Deficiencies
by Lorelei Stevens
When you sell property to a buyer and finance it yourself, do you really know
what obligations you are able to enforce? You know that if you carry a note
secured by real estate and your buyer fails to pay, you are able to take the
property back through foreclosure.
But, what if the property loses its value in the future? What if the economy of
the area collapses? What if the property is damaged or destroyed? Are you stuck
with a big loss? Maybe not. Sellers who seller-finance real estate in most
States and in most situations have the law on their side to take further steps.
Every State allows you to foreclose on the property and take it back. In many
cases, you will be able to re-sell the property for an amount equal to, or
greater than, what your buyer owes you on the note.
However, that requires the property to keep its value. What if the value of the
property falls? Now you have a deficiency between what was owing to you and what
you actually received. Many States allow you to enforce the promise on the note.
That means you can demand and receive the full amount owing on the note. Your
buyer may not realize this and refuse to pay the amount owing, saying that all
you can do is take the property back.
If your buyer has no other assets that could be applied to paying off the
deficiency, your buyer may be right. Legally you have an enforceable promise. In
practical terms, however, you would be wasting your time, money, and effort
trying to collect. It's the old saying "You can't squeeze blood out of a
turnip".
However, if your buyer owns other assets that can be attached, you may be
delighted to collect all the money your buyer owes you. If you have not obtained
a Financial Statement from the buyer, you will have no financial information on
the buyer, and no right to obtain it at this stage.
The obvious cure for this situation is to have created the note correctly to
begin with. The prudent seller will obtain a Financial Statement from the buyer
before selling the property. Then you will have valuable information you need to
collect a deficiency should one arise.
In the event of a default, your first step is to inform your buyer that you
intend to seek full payment on the note. If your buyer has assets to protect,
once they understand their personal liability, they will probably pay.
If you are faced with a deficiency, you need to be on guard and not lose your
presence of mind. Most buyers will act honorably and pay everything they owe.
But you need to be aware of a strategy that can be used to avoid paying the
deficiency. Your buyer may approach you with the offer to give the property back
to you through a "deed in lieu of foreclosure". This is a common, fast,
inexpensive way to give property back when your buyer falls into financial
trouble. If the property has maintained its value, this could be the best
choice.
But, if the property has lost value and there is a deficiency, it can be a bad
thing for you to do. Once you accept the deed in lieu of foreclosure, the
property is yours. You may have given up your legal right to collect any more
money from your buyer. A smart buyer may prey on your ignorance and try to get
out of paying a deficiency by offering you this easy alternative. You may be so
eager to solve the problem you neglect to ask your attorney about collecting the
deficiency.
When you seller-finance, you should obtain a Financial Statement from the buyer.
You should also consult an attorney before selling the property, and again in
the event of a default by your buyer.
Bio:
Lorelei Stevens is president of Wall Street Brokers, Inc. in Seattle,
Washington. She has been a licensed real estate broker (Washington State Real
Estate Brokers License WA-LL-SB-*275LD) and a discounted note buyer since the
1970s. She has worked her entire adult life with Wall Street Brokers negotiating
millions of dollars of paper and is a nationally recognized expert.
Lorelei has taught Legal Continuing Education seminars and has written numerous
articles for legal, real estate and other professional publications on the
subjects of seller-financing, managing, reinforcing and buying paper. She is the
author of two books, one on seller-financing and another on note buying. She
also writes a monthly column for Noteworthy Newsletter and is a frequent
contributor to The Paper Source. Her web site is www.WallStreetBrokers.com.